36-year-old Lindsay Shiver, a former Miss Houston County and 2nd runner-up in the National Peanut Festival pageant, is currently serving jail time in Nassau, Bahamas, over an alleged murder plan against her estranged husband, Robert Shiver, a former football player for the Auburn Tigers. The shocking revelation of her involvement in such a sinister plot has left many who knew her as a beauty queen in disbelief.
The Unraveling of the Murder Plot
Lindsay, who was once a proud mother of three and a noted supporter of former President Donald Trump, saw her life take a dramatic turn when Bahamian police accidentally uncovered the murder plot while investigating an unrelated burglary.
The authorities found incriminating WhatsApp messages detailing the plan on a suspect’s phone during a break-in at a bar and grill in Guana. The texts allegedly indicated that Lindsay had hired a hitman to execute her plan.
The Accomplices
Lindsay’s reported accomplices in this murder conspiracy included her alleged lover, Terrance Bethel, and another individual, Faron Newbold, who authorities suspect was hired as the hitman. All three were arrested and held in a jail facility in Nassau, facing charges related to the alleged murder plot.
A Life That Once Was
Lindsay Shiver’s Instagram account paints a stark contrast to her current circumstances. Her posts primarily featured her life as a dedicated wife, mother, and fitness enthusiast, enjoying her time in the Bahamas.
She and her husband, Robert, met during a fitness class at Auburn University in 2007. After his football career, Robert worked for the Senior Life Insurance Company.
However, their seemingly idyllic life was shattered when Robert filed for divorce after discovering Lindsay’s alleged extramarital affair with Terrance Bethel.
The Case Continues
The trio did not enter a plea during their initial court appearance, and their next court date is scheduled for October 5, 2023. The full extent of Lindsay Shiver’s jail sentence and the fate of her co-conspirators will be determined at the conclusion of the trial, and this case continues to stun those who once admired the former beauty queen.
The tale of Lindsay Shiver serves as a chilling reminder that appearances can be deceiving, and the pursuit of a life of crime can lead to devastating consequences.
